TS背叛者的逻辑问题

爱飞张的张飞

苏联放背叛者作为头条，美国可以得1vp吗？

逻辑上说不通啊
如果美国可以得1vp，背叛者就没发生作用取消苏联的头条背叛者
如果美国不能得1vp，背叛者没被执行为啥可以取消头条

cdm123cdm

本帖最后由 cdm123cdm 于 2010-5-5 16:32 编辑

苏联放背叛者头条什么事情都没有啊

背叛者的作用卡牌上写的很明白啊
1,[取消苏联头条事件]
2,[苏联方将背叛者作为行动点数打出美国方获得1VP,除非苏联投太空]

头条事件阶段除非卡牌上注明,否则无从获得行动点,自己手上对方卡牌的事件都是打出后强制触发,满足条件则使用,只是打出人决定先行动还是先事件

苏联在头条事件阶段打出背叛者执行
取消背叛者这个事件
苏联并没有获得行动点数
不满足事件触发条件
事件未被触发
美国自然得不到1分

这里有什么逻辑说不通的地方?

dsc311

不过苏联头条背叛者好像背叛者不移除吧

engasukip

没效果
不移除

cdm123cdm

背叛者本来就不是移除牌！

z1w0654

苏联不能投条背叛者吧,貌似

engasukip

苏联可以头条背叛者。

psychokiller

本帖最后由 psychokiller 于 2010-5-6 23:54 编辑

103 Defectors:

Q. What happens if the Soviet player plays Defectors in the headline phase?

A. Nothing. Defectors cancels itself and so has no effect during the headline phase and the Soviet player misses his opportunity to play the card during an action round for a Victory Point.

Q. If Defectors is played on the Space Race does the US earn a victory point?

A. Rule 6.4.5 declares that events played on the Space Race do not occur. Therefore, the text which would normally give the US a victory point would not take place. Therefore, the US would not earn a victory point.

http://talk.consimworld.com/WebX?233@415.hSCFa7Oe45l.0@.1dcfda60/8092!enclosure=.1dd1a049

psychokiller

the Soviet player misses his opportunity to play the card during an action round for a Victory Point ...
过隙之驹发表于 2010-5-7 01:09

它可能的意思是
the Soviet player misses his opportunity to play the card during an action round for a (US player's)Victory Point

爱飞张的张飞

# 103 Defectors:

Q. What happens if the Soviet player plays Defectors in the headline phase?

...
psychokiller 发表于 2010-5-6 23:52

这个清楚谢谢